Spotlight
Now is the time before Oscars and my local cinema program
is richer than usually. As the result, I have seen more films in the recent
times than earlier. I have seen The
Danish Girl and my personal Oscar for the best actor goes to Eddie Redmayne. I am
also rating costumes in Carol and The Danish Girl equal first.
esterday, I have seen The Spotlight and I am moved and even angry. I do
not think that the film itself is artistically particularly significant, but
the message is of great value, in my opinion. It is an eye opening message; I
hope it opens those eyes that would prefer to be closed on what is happening in
the Catholic Church. I may be reacting
to the film stronger than I normally do or maybe I should, but it touches my
personal experience. No, I was not molested, but I was hurt in my
feelings by the clergy and I was confused by evident hypocrisy when I was very
young and forming my views on what is good and what not.
Rotten Tomatoes says : “SPOTLIGHT
tells the riveting true story of the Pulitzer Prize-winning Boston Globe
investigation that would rock the city and cause a crisis in one of the world's
oldest and most trusted institutions. When the newspaper's tenacious
"Spotlight" team of reporters delves into allegations of abuse in the
Catholic Church, their year-long investigation uncovers a decades-long cover-up
at the highest levels of Boston 's religious,
legal, and government establishment, touching off a wave of revelations around
the world.”
The film shows bluntly that the church is guilty
of crimes of molesting children, hiding it, condoning future crimes even by the
same people, protecting the criminals and allowing them to continue preaching
on morality. To me this is horrible and unfortunately, I do not think much will
change in my life time. So, I am angry.
I hope many more people will get angry and maybe the situation will change
eventually.
My personal experience turned me against the Catholic
Church, but people need spirituality in their lives. I know, I do. So the
disappointed, disillusioned and hurt ones need a new religion or at least a new
belief. I found some affinity in Buddhism, but I was brought up as a catholic
and it was rather painful to be forced to find an alternative. I was still
lucky that I was excommunicated after a divorce and was
forced to find a new way. Otherwise I may have been as so many others shutting
my eyes on the church hypocrisy and crimes. So many people defend themselves from
losing their false spiritual support by doing that. In my case I was literally thrown out of the
church and humiliated in front of people who were at the time of my confession
in the church. It was just horrible. What I still have problems with is that I
was offered a “better deal” by a church representative in Sydney . Does that mean that rules
change from country to country? In the same church? Or that they sometimes
change over the years? The last eventuality may be acceptable. Anyhow, I have
decided not to take a better offer as far communion after a divorce is
concerned and now simply believe in honesty, kindness, integrity and few other
things. Something like my personal religion and faith in goodness.
Back to movies, I rate Carol 6 out of 10, The
Danish Girl 7 out of 10 and Spotlight 7 out of 10.
P.S. I have read many positive reviews on The Spotlight since I wrote my original post. The last Sunday the film received four Satellite Awards of International Press Academy including the best picture. Looks that my personal opinion does not agree with the general one and the film is nominated also for a number of Oscar awards including the best film, Mark Ruffalo as actor in supporting role, Rachel McAdams as actress in supporting role, directing, film editing and original screenplay. Even though I mainly focused on the subject of the film, I am happy that others have not been blinded as I possibly was.
I am very sorry about your experience with Catholic Church. You asked if rules change from country to country. Well, maybe not exactly rules , but their practical interpretation.
ReplyDeleteI have a funny experience in that matter. My daughter was to be married in a Catholic Church in the country, in Bright. She and her partner visited parish priest to make all formal arrangements and asked me to accompany them.
First of all when we entered the parish building we found terrible mess and very embarrassed priest. My comment was: Father, you need a woman here.
Then the priest checked credentials of the couple to be wed. My daughter got everything right , certificates of baptism, first communion, confirmation. Then it comes to her partner, he is getting red on face.... sorry but I am not baptized. This was surprise to everybody.
I just stood up - sorry Father for wasting your time, we are not entitled to Catholic marriage.
He rebuked me - what a terrible father in law you will make. Of course everything is in order. I just cannot give formal blessing to the groom , as it means nothing to him.
I know, that in Poland, in most parishes , the priest would not let them a wed in the church.
I laught at your suggestion that the priest needed a woman there. But in fact this one of the things that upset me in my young years. Many priests have a housekeeper in Poland, and their duties are often similar to those of a wife. I was disturbed by seeing such cases.
DeleteThe rest of your story is nice and warm. This is how ideally I would like to see priests and their actions. I know that there are exceptions like the one you described, thanks God for such examples.
So, a lesbian love affair, a tragic transgender story, and (possibly church enabled) paedofilia. No wonder "people need spirituality in their lives" if these are subjects of significant interest. But I suspect not; I think the interest is more akin to voyeurism than any real interest.
ReplyDeleteAnd please do not take this comment as in any way judgemental of either lesbians or trans people; I think people should be free to exist however they wish - provided they do no harm to others.
The third category fails this test.
kvd
ps I'm interested in any proof you have that "people need spirituality"? I think you are reaching there.
Interesting comment, hmm... I wonder if it is directed at people who produce such films, people who watch them or people who write about it. Or is it simply only a comment on my post.
DeleteMy answer will be only on my own behalf. I was not particularly interested in the subjects of The Danish Girl or Carol. I heard that Eddie Redmayne performance was particularly good and I wanted to compare it to Di Caprio in The Revenant. In my opinion Eddie Redmayne should win hands down even if I have small hopes for that.
I saw Carol because Cate Blanchett is an Australian and I follow her performances. It looks that Carol was even made especially for her. However, I was not that impressed by her perormance in this particular production. I must say that I did not receive anything akin to sexual gratification watching either of those films.
My real interest was the third of the films and this is what my post was all about.
By the way, I do not think I need spirituality in my life due to any possible psychological problems. I think that it is one of components of a healthy life. Definitely of my life, to avoid generalization. Maybe you are right that I went too far, I do not have a proof, I just think so.
Please accept that my earlier comment was general in nature - not directed specifically at you, and certainly not meant as personal criticism. It was just a general muse upon what interests all of us as audience.
DeleteOn the other hand, my question re spirituality was directed to you: it is an interesting subject, about which I have no definite personal opinion, hence was intrigued by your seeming certainty. Thank you for the follow up.
kvd
The way atheism is being sold by the likes of Richard Dawkins, that too is becoming a religion of sorts! There is a core belief, there are evangelicals and there is a serious attempt at proselytisation. All these qualify to call it a religion. Yes, we need something to hold on to and when what we are born into does not offer the elusive something, an alternative is sought and the journey itself becomes a spiritual one.
ReplyDeleteI like the way you phrased it. I seem to be still on my spiritual journey. Meandering a bit, but this is a good process.
ReplyDelete